| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Simon Phoenix |
Posted - 09 May 2013 : 16:43:30
Is mystra the goddess of magic just on abeir/toril, or throughout the multiverse?
Mod edit: Relocated scroll.  |
| 10 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| CorellonsDevout |
Posted - 24 Jul 2013 : 04:01:10
@Erik: I'm hoping after the six Sundering novels, they will start releasing other novels, too. Since the Sundering takes place in 1486, is your next Shadowbane novel going to take place post-Sundering, too? |
| Ayrik |
Posted - 24 Jul 2013 : 02:39:00
The simplest - non-canon - explanation might be that Mystra rules supreme over magic in the Realms, while of course any number of other deities rule supreme over magic in their worlds, yet the magic itself is a semi-constant component almost everywhere. All sorts of metaphors might apply, for instance:
Magic might be fundamentally present almost everywhere throughout the cosmos ... sort of a big multiverse-spanning "ocean", shallow and fickle near some world-islands, sluggish and profoundly deep near others ... various deities of magic might construct "bridges" or "canals" or "tide gates" or "harbours" or "rafts" (or floating "Weaves") to somehow accumulate or isolate or direct or filter magic around their particular "islands" in a more accessible or controlled fashion. And when one of these large-scale constructs violently erupts or sinks it disrupts all others on (and under) the surface, massive tsunamis and hurricanes could drown many adjacent worlds, even the most minor ripples could still be felt on worlds separated by vast distances. |
| jerrod |
Posted - 22 Jul 2013 : 22:57:03
Ao gave mystra dominion over toril. Anywhere in realms space she is over the weave. But in places like krynn she does not rule.the dragonlance gods are very close border about interloper gods and WILL attack them if they attempt to enter without permission from the greater gods. Even wih permission,the gods of magic there will unite to destroy the outsider. Even clerics from other worlds are required to convert to be able to cast their spells. |
| Erik Scott de Bie |
Posted - 10 May 2013 : 01:15:26
@Mirtek: I expect that is indeed how it worked, that Cyric was just so accustomed to using Weave magic, and when suddenly that was denied to him, he didn't know how to use non-Weave magic, due to his inexperience as a god. As we've seen, adjusting from the easy-plug-and-play channeling of the Weave to drawing the raw forces of magic from the world directly is a frustrating, time-consuming, and not always sure process. After 1385, with the Weave suddenly no longer an option, it took most spellcasters in the Realms years to accomplish the transition, and many never succeeded at it. One might expect a god could do it faster, as Cyric did.
Cheers |
| Mirtek |
Posted - 10 May 2013 : 00:07:45
In one novel, either Prince of Lies or Crucible, Mystra denies Cyric the use of magic and he is unable to use magic even on the planes.
In Magic of Faerun (3e supplement) it states that Mystra's ability to deny the weave only hinders on the material plane on Toril, but not on the planes where such an individual could work magic as usual despite being baned from the weave.
Cyric also "recovers" from the ban in a later fight with Mystra by just drawing power diretly from the fabric of the plane they are fighting on. So maybe he was just so used to work magic "the Mystra" way that his initial loss of magic was simply him not realizing that he could just draw on magic in a different way. |
| Rhymn |
Posted - 09 May 2013 : 21:40:53
Lore said that Ao created the universe in which Toril came to exist, and from the protoplasm of this creation came Selune and Shar. As they fought, Selune tore out a piece of her own essence and hurled it at Shar, and from both essences came Mystryl, Mystra's predecessor.
Since Selune and Shar were created from the raw essence of the universe, and Mystryl was created to be Selune's ally, it would seem to follow that the goddess of magic holds her title for every world in Ao's creation, just as Selune and Shar would hold their respective titles and portfolios. This would probably not hold true for Chauntea or other gods tied to Toril. |
| Erik Scott de Bie |
Posted - 09 May 2013 : 19:08:35
quote:
Originally posted by Simon Phoenix
The reason I asked is that because in all the books I'm reading everybody freaks over magic not working right because of the spellplague. Shouldn't everybody's spells work just fine on other planes?
The Realms has an ambiguous relationship with the rest of the D&D multiverse. The novels and even the sourcebooks may talk about the cosmology, but they rarely discuss other settings. Partly, this is to keep the focus on the Realms, and partly this is because the exact way the multiverse functions can vary widely from campaign to campaign. Generally, though, it's fairly unlikely that Mystra is *the* goddess of magic in the multiverse. She's powerful but not THAT powerful, and I doubt the other deities on those other worlds would stand for it anyway.
quote:
Like, I just finished bury elminster deep. Shouldn't el be able to take himself and the simbul to another plane and work magic without going crazy? Maybe even cure her?
Good question. He might not have the necessary magic to travel between worlds, and even if he did, he's still using the magic he's accumulated from centuries in the Realms--magic that is so intimately tied to Mystra--which is still broken and strange. Just because he goes to another plane doesn't mean he necessarily picks up that plane's magic.
And even if it all worked out--he took the Simbul to another plane and "cured" her insanity--it's entirely possible she'd go insane again as soon as they went back to the Realms. It's the question of "do I stay here where things are bad, but at least I can make a difference" or "do I flee and retire elsewhere"? And Elminster has never been the type to back down.
quote:
Also, can't wait for your next book!
I'm gratified that you enjoy my work. It may be a while, however.
WotC is focused on the Sundering event and AFAIK has no plans to release books by any authors other than the Sundering Six. Depending on how well the Sundering does, they may expand their publishing agenda once again afterward. We'll see.
Cheers |
| Kentinal |
Posted - 09 May 2013 : 19:06:46
Some deities clearly have presence on more then one plane, some deities however only held sway over one plane. In Forgotten Realms magic works best by use of the Weave, other planes the Weave does not exist as I understand it. Oh magic and spells tend to work about the same, however the reason that magic works on other planes is because of other magical sources of power not the Weave. |
| Simon Phoenix |
Posted - 09 May 2013 : 18:29:20
I only read the books, so I usually don't go to other sections, sorry. The reason I asked is that because in all the books I'm reading everybody freaks over magic not working right because of the spellplague. Shouldn't everybody's spells work just fine on other planes? Like, I just finished bury elminster deep. Shouldn't el be able to take himself and the simbul to another plane and work magic without going crazy? Maybe even cure her?
Also, can't wait for your next book! |
| Erik Scott de Bie |
Posted - 09 May 2013 : 16:50:41
We have yet to see an exception, and your campaign may have it however you want it, but generally speaking, Mystra (and her former incarnations) only have sway over magic in Realmspace. There are lots of gods of magic elsewhere in the multiverse that have little to nothing to do with Mystra.
(Also, this thread should probably go in the General Discussion or Realmslore sections!)
Cheers |
|
|
