Candlekeep Forum
Candlekeep Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Members | Private Messages | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Forgotten Realms Journals
 Running the Realms
 Scyllua Darkhope from 1368-1375
 New Topic  New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 2

rangerstranger
Seeker

USA
37 Posts

Posted - 13 Sep 2019 :  19:48:22  Show Profile Send rangerstranger a Private Message  Reply with Quote  Delete Topic
So, I am DMing a campaign set in the Dales region. The current month and year are Eleasis 1368 DR. I have a bunch of ideas and modules I want to sorta mesh together but the timeline is going to need some manipulating. So here are a list of items I want to weave together and the years in which they occur in cannon, according to my knowledge of the realms. I would like to know what the scribes here at Candlekeep think about my ideas.

1. The Randal Morn Trilogy. (Fall 1368?) I want to have Scyllua Darkhope appear in this somewhere, before she begins her fall from grace. I've already run the Doom of Daggerdale in a different campaign with some of the players who are also in this campaign. I was thinking of having her come to the Daggerfalls in the aftermath to secure the trade routes across Anauroch or maybe deal with Colderan, who got away. Perhaps the party meets Scyllua along with a Zhentilar Patrol and Randal Morn with some of his freedom riders arguing along the Tethymar Trail south of the Falls, perhaps the same ones that get attacked at the beginning of the Sword of the Dales. I think this makes sense, but feel free to critique. Hopefully the party leaves a good impression on Scyllua, and she could call upon them to help in the Keep before it's destruction. The lands they receive from Lhaeo in Shadowdale may become an issue as I want to run Shadowdale: Scouring the Land to cap off the campaign.

2. I also want the Party to be present in Zhentil Keep during the siege in late 1368 or early 1369. While in the Keep I'd like for them go through the siege and also become good friends with Scyllua during her ascent of the ranks in the Zhentilar and also meet some of the Lords of Zhentil Keep, like Fzoul, Orgauth (before Arbarax), and Desmonda (before Eshaeris). After the destruction I'd like to run them through the Ruins of Zhentil Keep adventure where Iyachtu Xvim ascends to an intermediate or lesser deity (I'm not sure the name of this adventure.) Also after the destruction I'd like to have them interact with Orgauth when he repents and promises to Scyllua to help turn Zhentil keep around, especially now that the Zhentarim have left the city. I'd like to see how they deal with Arbarax and Eshaesis after taking the places of Orgauth and Desmonda. This could maybe link into the next step of the campaign.

3. Either from Orgauth or Desmonda, or maybe from Scyllua herself the characters learn about some documents in Scardale that indicate Scyllua's father to be Lashan, and in theory, the rightful ruler of Scardale. This has the characters going off to Scardale to find said documents and then, with Scyllua, have them approach the rulers of the other dales, the Zhentilar, the purple dragons present in Scardale to have her put in place as the city's new leader and end the anarchy. Despite her being a Paladin of Tyr, all but the Zhentilar are fearful of another "Lashan" conquering the dales and reject the documents as fakes. Especially as some of the leaders of the dales are informed by Khelben that Orgauth is infact Arbarax, Fzoul would learn this before or after this event and the Harper schism would happen at this point, some characters may join the harpers by this point so this could be interesting. Scyllua vehemently denies the fact she has been fooled by Arbarax and this would be the catalyst of her falling from grace. She becomes resentful of the Dales and their leaders and leaves for Zhentil Keep to plot her revenge. This doubt leaves her as easy prey for "Orgauth", and he assists in completing her fall from grace. Depending on the characters action, she will complete her fall and join the Zhentarrim or retire from the Zhentilar settle in some small town either in the dales or the Moonsea.

4. Cormyr: Tearing the Weave. Fall of 1374. This date would have to be brought forward I think but not before 1372 when Tilverton is destroyed. I can probably have Tunaster appear in daggerfalls in part 1. He could have been their investigating the Dream Fever and also know a bit about these heroes. Perhaps have them build a personal connection. This would provide an easy hook for this adventure when the time comes.

5. Shadowdale: Scouring the Land. 1375. Probably pushed forward as well. Depending on the events of part 3. Scyllua would either fight along with the Zhentarrim as is cannon or if she left the Zhentilar she could be coaxed out of retirement by the party and redeem herself.

My big issue is with the documents found in Scardale is suppose to happen in 1372 after Scyllua has clearly fallen, according to the 3E FRCS. I'd like to rewrite it as the catalyst for her fall, and give the party the chance to talk her off the ledge so to speak.

Also the details surrounding Fzoul discovering Orgauth's true identity evades me. I don't understand why Khelben told Fzoul and I don't understand Khelben's motivations to make the deal with Fzoul and the Zhentarim but I'd like to use that to try event steer Scyllua toward the Zhentarim and Iyachtu Xvim. Maybe Bane after his return, if I have that happen.

Yeah sounds like I have a ton of stuff planned and the last thing I want to do is railroad the characters into "MY" adventure. So I'll just have things go as they did in cannon if the party/campaign goes another direction. They haven't been too difficult to subtly steer in one direction or another but sometimes things go way off the rails and that's fine.

Anyway I'd like hear everyone's opinions of my ideas. What things should I add in to make things a little more nuanced? Am I just way off on certain events? What could I add in or take out?

Thanks

ericlboyd
Forgotten Realms Designer

USA
1544 Posts

Posted - 13 Sep 2019 :  23:35:13  Show Profile  Visit ericlboyd's Homepage Send ericlboyd a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Lot of interesting ideas to noodle on.

I would look at the Leaves of the One Night, the Book of the Black, and the Dark Diviners.

https://forgottenrealms.fandom.com/wiki/The_Leaves_of_One_Night

You might be able to weave some of that in.

--
http://www.ericlboyd.com/dnd/

Edited by - ericlboyd on 14 Sep 2019 13:20:55
Go to Top of Page

ericlboyd
Forgotten Realms Designer

USA
1544 Posts

Posted - 14 Sep 2019 :  13:10:54  Show Profile  Visit ericlboyd's Homepage Send ericlboyd a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I assume you saw that Lashan appears in Shadowdale: Scouring of the Land, page 57, in the form of a nycaloth.

Could make for an interesting plot twist for Scyllua to confront her dad, if you want her to have a redemption arc.

--Eric

--
http://www.ericlboyd.com/dnd/

Edited by - ericlboyd on 14 Sep 2019 13:16:28
Go to Top of Page

sleyvas
Great Reader

USA
8344 Posts

Posted - 14 Sep 2019 :  18:51:54  Show Profile Send sleyvas a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Hmmm, that's an interesting idea having Scyllua Darkhope the child of Lashan of Scardale. BTW, did Lashan's last name ever get published, and I'm assuming she took on the name "Darkhope" for a reason after her fall. That might be interesting to work on. Then again, that MIGHT be easy since there's also Teldorn Darkhope who is also a Zhentů maybe its a religious last name. Then again... maybe they are related as well?

Alavairthae, may your skill prevail

Phillip aka Sleyvas

Edited by - sleyvas on 14 Sep 2019 18:53:51
Go to Top of Page

Gary Dallison
Great Reader

United Kingdom
4765 Posts

Posted - 14 Sep 2019 :  19:00:55  Show Profile Send Gary Dallison a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Wasnt Lashan aumersair which turned out to make him related to elminster - I asked Ed (I cant remember if there was another dale tyrant that was an aumersair and I'm confusing the two).

I'd make darkhope a title from the church of xvim or bane as there is little likelihood of scyllua and teldorn being related given the huge geographic separation.

Kind of makes you wonder what is in elminster genetics that makes two of his relatives so horribly evil.

Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions Candlekeep Archive
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 1
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 2
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 3
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 4
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 5
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 6
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 7
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 8
Forgotten Realms Alternate Dimensions: Issue 9

Alternate Realms Site
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 14 Sep 2019 :  19:04:49  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by ericlboyd

I assume you saw that Lashan appears in Shadowdale: Scouring of the Land, page 57, in the form of a nycaloth.

Could make for an interesting plot twist for Scyllua to confront her dad, if you want her to have a redemption arc.

--Eric



Lashan the Nycaloth almost destroyed our entire party during that module. Our DM had to implement divine intervention from Erevan Ilesere to win the battle. I'm not sure that Scyllua is a high enough level to destroy her father in one on one combat.

Our party consisted of Curudin Ahmaquissar: Trickster-Touched Moon elf Rogue 5/ Cleric 5/ Mischiefmaker 5/ Shadowtrick Priest 5 of Erevan Ilesere.

Lairlefain Starleaf: Copper elf Rogue 5/ Swashbuckler 10/ Shadowblade 5.

Terrindill Shaelarra: Gold elf Rogue 10/ Shadowdancer 10.

Pheyloo Audark: Wild elf Rogue 5/ Assassin 10/ Quietknife 5.

Nym Nightsong: Star elf Rogue 5/ Sorcerer 5/ Shadowmage 10.

All 20th level PC's. In the end of the module we had our epic battle against Her Nycaloth father and herself, and our DM had to send an Avatar of Erevan to even up the fight. I do understand that the module is not a "High-level" adventure, but our DM tweaked all the stats in the game to bring everything up to a 15th thru 20th level module.

Even at the normal level adventure, I'm not sure Scyulla could defeat her father in single combat for redemption. unless her redemption was to die at her fathers hands to save the party. A basic, standard Nycaloth is powerful to begin with. Now add class levels to his profile and Ka-pow... you have a CR 20 Nycaloth minimum. It's that kind of horror that helped Myth Drannor fall before the elven crusade. Even the legendary elven warrior Starbrow was slain in combat fighting a Nycaloth during the fall of that city.

Just saying that not every demon or devil or Nycaloth is standard black and white stats. Most of the more prominent ones have class levels in something. A Nycaloth is a Nycaloth... but then add 10 levels of fighter or sorcerer to a particular prominent Nycaloth and you have a denizen of the lower planes that Scyllua cannot hope to defeat herself.

It would make a great redemption arc if she helped the PC's to slay her father, or die doing so. But she couldn't slay him herself unless the DM was sleeping. lol.
Go to Top of Page

rangerstranger
Seeker

USA
37 Posts

Posted - 14 Sep 2019 :  20:30:08  Show Profile Send rangerstranger a Private Message  Reply with Quote
The Leaves of one Night, and the Book of the Black are exactly the type of things I'd like to weave in, at least in the background. My knowledge of the 3E lore concerning the Shadovar is a little lacking but these ideas certainly give me something to consider. That's kinda terrible considering that was the bulk of 3E.

We are using the 5E rules and one of PCs is a Way of the Shadow monk. But rather being part of a clan or monastery, he was a charlatan that was pretending to be a wizard's apprentice and stealing components and the odd scroll. Well he stole the components that were part of a ritual where this wizard was scrying on something in the plane of shadow. During the scrying something went wrong due to the missing components and the tower exploded. He somehow was protected by the plane of shadow and this will explain is odd kii powers. He's also thinking of dipping into shadow sorcerer as well to kinda bring forward the fact that he is essentially plane touched.

Scyllua confronting her father in the form of a nycaloth would indeed be interesting. It's been a few years since I've read through Scouring of the Land of the land but do remember, now that you mention it that Lashan is present in the module/adventure.

Sleyvas and Gary - Scyllua being Lashan's daughter is not my idea, but I agree, it is an interesting one. It's on pg 137 of the 3E Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting. From reading whats in the book, it sounds more like a Zhent ploy and the documents are fake. Also considering that Scyllua is already super evil by that point in the cannon, I would also think this LOL. She also got her name from the family that bought her and her mother as slaves. They were from the dales originally and brought to Zhentil Keep against their will. She simply took the name of her owner after she got her freedom. I think this person was also related to Teldorn. Changing her name will be something I will certainly do. It's a little too forward and I don't want to hint at her connection to Teldorn. Darkhope being a title in the Zhentarim, the church of Bane or Xvim sound like good ideas.

Copper Elven Vampire - Lashan the Nycaloth is presented as a CR10 in th 3E module and they are CR9 in 5E. If Scyllua is 12 level or more by the time this part of the module happens it should be a winnable fight. I see what you are saying about throwing some class levels on the Nycaloth to increase the challenge. I'll consider this once I get to that part of the campaign.

Edited by - rangerstranger on 14 Sep 2019 20:31:38
Go to Top of Page

rangerstranger
Seeker

USA
37 Posts

Posted - 14 Sep 2019 :  20:33:42  Show Profile Send rangerstranger a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Gary Dallison


Kind of makes you wonder what is in elminster genetics that makes two of his relatives so horribly evil.



Damn Elminster, such a dead-beat great great great grandfather.
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 14 Sep 2019 :  21:01:18  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
After playing the 3 module campaign I have always wondered why no living clones of Manshoon weren't present.

I mean, the Vampire Manshoon from Westgate alone could wipe the floor with Fzoul in my opinion. a 20th level arcane caster, plus a Vampire Lord to boot?? Wow. pretty powerful indeed. That's actually more powerful than the REAL Manshoon, lol. So I never understood how Fzoul continued to rule the Zhents uncontested. Maybe the Manshoon wars made the surviving clones realize that they had better things to do? lol.

You're not going to slay a Nycaloth at 5th level, or even at 10th level. Fzoul himself would be hard pressed to slay a Nycaloth without any class levels involved. Maybe whatever deal he made with "The Blackstaff" had something to do with it all.

Hadrhune alone could possibly kill Fzoul in this campaign the way it is stated. But even Hadrhune would find it difficult to slay a Nycaloth on his own.
Go to Top of Page

rangerstranger
Seeker

USA
37 Posts

Posted - 17 Sep 2019 :  15:49:53  Show Profile Send rangerstranger a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Copper Elven Vampire

After playing the 3 module campaign I have always wondered why no living clones of Manshoon weren't present.

I mean, the Vampire Manshoon from Westgate alone could wipe the floor with Fzoul in my opinion. a 20th level arcane caster, plus a Vampire Lord to boot?? Wow. pretty powerful indeed. That's actually more powerful than the REAL Manshoon, lol. So I never understood how Fzoul continued to rule the Zhents uncontested. Maybe the Manshoon wars made the surviving clones realize that they had better things to do? lol.

You're not going to slay a Nycaloth at 5th level, or even at 10th level. Fzoul himself would be hard pressed to slay a Nycaloth without any class levels involved. Maybe whatever deal he made with "The Blackstaff" had something to do with it all.

Hadrhune alone could possibly kill Fzoul in this campaign the way it is stated. But even Hadrhune would find it difficult to slay a Nycaloth on his own.



Very rarely do battles come down to one on one duels. Fzoul had help in slaying manshoon the first time and there is no reason to believe he wasn't ready for one of Manshoon's clones to come back to claim the Leadership of the Zhentarim for it's own. I think Fzoul even had one of the Manshoon Clones on working inside the Zhentarim. So while it is interesting that this clone did not show up in the Tearing of the Weave, Scouring of the Land or The empire of Shade, I also see why no other Manshoon clones showed themselves. It was far to dangerous of an event and way too many powerful players were at work. The Zhentarim, the Churches of Shar and Bane, the Drow, the Shades, Elminster and the other chosen of Midnight and the Harpers. Plus the PCs. These guys always seem to come out of nowhere.
Go to Top of Page

LordofBones
Senior Scribe

961 Posts

Posted - 18 Sep 2019 :  06:03:10  Show Profile Send LordofBones a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Copper Elven Vampire

After playing the 3 module campaign I have always wondered why no living clones of Manshoon weren't present.

quote:
I mean, the Vampire Manshoon from Westgate alone could wipe the floor with Fzoul in my opinion. a 20th level arcane caster, plus a Vampire Lord to boot?? Wow. pretty powerful indeed. That's actually more powerful than the REAL Manshoon, lol.


The real wizard Giovanni is 25th level.

quote:
You're not going to slay a Nycaloth at 5th level, or even at 10th level. Fzoul himself would be hard pressed to slay a Nycaloth without any class levels involved. Maybe whatever deal he made with "The Blackstaff" had something to do with it all.


A nycaloth is CR 10. 10th level parties are absolutely capable of killing it.

Fzoul without class levels would be kind of dead, seeing as how a humanoid is defined by its class levels. He's also fully capable of trivially killing a nycaloth, given that he's a 17th level cleric with access to 9th level spells.

[quote] Hadrhune alone could possibly kill Fzoul in this campaign the way it is stated. But even Hadrhune would find it difficult to slay a Nycaloth on his own.


Haddy, being a 20th level wizard, is capable of trivially killing lots of nycaloths. Even if you scaled up nycaloths to their baatezu and tanar'ri counterparts, they'd still be CR 14, at most.

You need the big three (pit fiend, balor, theoretical CR 20 ultroloth) to deal with 20th level parties. Of course, they'd have to be intelligently played.
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 21 Sep 2019 :  06:07:09  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by LordofBones

quote:
Originally posted by Copper Elven Vampire

After playing the 3 module campaign I have always wondered why no living clones of Manshoon weren't present.

quote:
I mean, the Vampire Manshoon from Westgate alone could wipe the floor with Fzoul in my opinion. a 20th level arcane caster, plus a Vampire Lord to boot?? Wow. pretty powerful indeed. That's actually more powerful than the REAL Manshoon, lol.


The real wizard Giovanni is 25th level.

quote:
You're not going to slay a Nycaloth at 5th level, or even at 10th level. Fzoul himself would be hard pressed to slay a Nycaloth without any class levels involved. Maybe whatever deal he made with "The Blackstaff" had something to do with it all.


A nycaloth is CR 10. 10th level parties are absolutely capable of killing it.

Fzoul without class levels would be kind of dead, seeing as how a humanoid is defined by its class levels. He's also fully capable of trivially killing a nycaloth, given that he's a 17th level cleric with access to 9th level spells.

[quote] Hadrhune alone could possibly kill Fzoul in this campaign the way it is stated. But even Hadrhune would find it difficult to slay a Nycaloth on his own.


Haddy, being a 20th level wizard, is capable of trivially killing lots of nycaloths. Even if you scaled up nycaloths to their baatezu and tanar'ri counterparts, they'd still be CR 14, at most.

You need the big three (pit fiend, balor, theoretical CR 20 ultroloth) to deal with 20th level parties. Of course, they'd have to be intelligently played.



Absolutely correct on all accounts. So what levels were the 3 Nycaloths that destroyed Myth Drannor? Even Fflar... a legendary elven warrior died at their claws. By 2ED standards Fflar was a fighter of no less than 20th level. In 3.5ed Fflar was resurrected as a Fighter 20/ Champion of Corellon 10. Yet he would be hard pressed to defeat Malkazid, the unholy Solar. Which in game terms would be a Arch-Duke of Hell I assume. Total guess there.
Go to Top of Page

TBeholder
Master of Realmslore

1887 Posts

Posted - 21 Sep 2019 :  21:50:46  Show Profile Send TBeholder a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Copper Elven Vampire


So what levels were the 3 Nycaloths that destroyed Myth Drannor?
A standard Nycaloth (Yugoloth, Greater) is HD11+22
They also had an army, however.

quote:
Even Fflar... a legendary elven warrior died at their claws. By 2ED standards Fflar was a fighter of no less than 20th level.

Wrong. He was so non-legendary that no survivor knew who he is beyond the first name, until he got resurrected.
We know stats of his boss (deceased by that time): Arms-Major Kelvhan Olortynnal (NG gold em F16). Kelvhan got there via a field promotion, and was groomed for this post as his teacher - and he was a master strategist, not duelist, of course. Still, he was fit for it.

To have some benchmarks for warriors' notability vs. levels, let's look at the elves' stats in Cormanthyr and The Fall of Myth Drannor:
F25/W19 - 1: the Coronal.
F24 - 0.
F23 - 1: a clan Patriarch.
R22 - 1, co-founder of the Harpers. FMD:+1: senior officer.
F22 - 0.
R21 - 2: a clan Elder, a clan Patriarch.
F21 - 1: a clan Heir. FMD:+1: a clan Heir
R20 - 0
F20 - 0
R19 - 1: a clan Patriarch.
F19 - 2: a clan Elder, a clan Patriarch.
R18 - 1: a clan Patriarch.
F18 - 0
R17 - 0
F17 - 1: commander of a military outpost with reputation of "the finest archer who ever lived". FMD:+1: senior officer.
F16/W14 - FMD:+1: senior officer in magic corps, chief of black ops corps.
F16 - 4: 2 clan Elders, commander of the dragonriders and commander of the "mundane" army.
F15/W15 - 2: commander of the Moonshadows "special forces", clan Elder. FMD:+1: (bladesinger) Spell-Major.
R15 - 1: a clan Heir and Arms-Captain (also, second-in-command of "mundane" forces).
F15 - 1: a clan Heir.
You get the picture.

People never wonder How the world goes round -Helloween
And even I make no pretense Of having more than common sense -R.W.Wood
It's not good, Eric. It's a gazebo. -Ed Whitchurch
Go to Top of Page

LordofBones
Senior Scribe

961 Posts

Posted - 22 Sep 2019 :  00:12:28  Show Profile Send LordofBones a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Richard Baker noted that Fflar is around 16th to 20th level. Malkizid is CR 26 with 20th level cleric casting.
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 23 Sep 2019 :  21:54:00  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by LordofBones

Richard Baker noted that Fflar is around 16th to 20th level. Malkizid is CR 26 with 20th level cleric casting.



16th to 20th is a bit of a gap, but not too huge. Enough to die or live certainly.

Malkizid is CR 26 with 20th level cleric casting. He would wipe the floor with my CR 26 Wild elf Rogue 5/ Assassin 10/ Quietknife 10 (even with the Shadow-walker template). Even if you're not hack-n-slash, or sling-n-slay types, My wild elf would be hard pressed to kill the Anti-Solor/ Arch-Duke, whatever he is.
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 23 Sep 2019 :  22:08:07  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by TBeholder

quote:
Originally posted by Copper Elven Vampire


So what levels were the 3 Nycaloths that destroyed Myth Drannor?
A standard Nycaloth (Yugoloth, Greater) is HD11+22
They also had an army, however.

quote:
Even Fflar... a legendary elven warrior died at their claws. By 2ED standards Fflar was a fighter of no less than 20th level.

Wrong. He was so non-legendary that no survivor knew who he is beyond the first name, until he got resurrected.
We know stats of his boss (deceased by that time): Arms-Major Kelvhan Olortynnal (NG gold em F16). Kelvhan got there via a field promotion, and was groomed for this post as his teacher - and he was a master strategist, not duelist, of course. Still, he was fit for it.

To have some benchmarks for warriors' notability vs. levels, let's look at the elves' stats in Cormanthyr and The Fall of Myth Drannor:
F25/W19 - 1: the Coronal.
F24 - 0.
F23 - 1: a clan Patriarch.
R22 - 1, co-founder of the Harpers. FMD:+1: senior officer.
F22 - 0.
R21 - 2: a clan Elder, a clan Patriarch.
F21 - 1: a clan Heir. FMD:+1: a clan Heir
R20 - 0
F20 - 0
R19 - 1: a clan Patriarch.
F19 - 2: a clan Elder, a clan Patriarch.
R18 - 1: a clan Patriarch.
F18 - 0
R17 - 0
F17 - 1: commander of a military outpost with reputation of "the finest archer who ever lived". FMD:+1: senior officer.
F16/W14 - FMD:+1: senior officer in magic corps, chief of black ops corps.
F16 - 4: 2 clan Elders, commander of the dragonriders and commander of the "mundane" army.
F15/W15 - 2: commander of the Moonshadows "special forces", clan Elder. FMD:+1: (bladesinger) Spell-Major.
R15 - 1: a clan Heir and Arms-Captain (also, second-in-command of "mundane" forces).
F15 - 1: a clan Heir.
You get the picture.



A standard Nycaloth (Yugoloth, Greater) is HD11+22.

So a CR of 33 maximum? That makes Malkizid look like an Arch-Duke of gerbers baby food. lol.

It also mentions that the 3 Nycaloths were NOT standard... they were advanced for their kind.

An ancient elven city with a functioning mythal would not fall to 3 standard Nycaloths and a hoard of bugbears, orcs, ogres, and more unless there was something more involved. From the list you describe above, there were more than enough elves with sufficient power to combat the evil.
Go to Top of Page

LordofBones
Senior Scribe

961 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  01:04:09  Show Profile Send LordofBones a Private Message  Reply with Quote
11 HD with 22 bonus hp, not CR 33.
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  05:45:18  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by LordofBones

11 HD with 22 bonus hp, not CR 33.




Well, that's ludicrous... An 11HD fiend (22 added HP is paltry) slaying elves of 20+HD is absurd. Not to mention a city full of them. 3 Nycaloths at 11HD +22 HP and an army of orcs, goblins, ogres, Bugbears, and humanoid shamans would NEVER destroy a city of elves encompassed by a living Mythal that prevents just such a thing. That hoard would have to be 100,000,000 strong to even breach the boundaries of the city proper, let alone slay all their most powerful warriors, wizards, clerics and druids. Not to mention the epic Scouts, Sorcerers, Bladesingers, Duskblades, Bards and Spell-Singers. Then you have the lesser artists, such as stone masons, gem artificers, cloth weavers, road builders and Chefs.

I find it ludicrous that an army led by 3 Nycaloths could so destroy a city of such powerful magic. I've had this same discussion with several friends pertaining to this very matter. We all agree that the size of the army doesn't matter at all, as the Mythal takes care of that. It lies within how powerful the 3 Nycaloths were.

11HD+22HP would be slain by the Coronal himself.

11HD+22HP would be slain by the Archmage of Cormanthyr.

11HD+22HP would be slain by the master at arms.

That's all 3 Nycaloths.

Please explain to me how the city fell, besides a good plot line for future adventures?

Hell... My above mentioned wild elf rogue 5/ assassin 10/ Quietknife 10 would clean the floor with 1 Nycaloth at those stats, let alone the Coronal of the kingdom. Also consider that the Coronal was fighting with THE RULERS BLADE!
Go to Top of Page

LordofBones
Senior Scribe

961 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  05:58:03  Show Profile Send LordofBones a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Novels and histories are independent of statistics. Power of plot, essentially.

And also because progression of gameplay editions, like Drizzt against Errtu.
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  07:24:31  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by LordofBones

Novels and histories are independent of statistics. Power of plot, essentially.

And also because progression of gameplay editions, like Drizzt against Errtu.



Here we go... Drizzt vs. Errtu... Drizzt is stated as a 18th level NPC, so CR 19 due to him being a drow. Errtu is NOT a standard Balor... He owns his own throne in the abyss. That is very much known. Most Balors work for a demon lord or prince or princess of the abyss. But Errtu himself is possibly a Demon lord. Errtu is no simple Balor.

That being said... Drizzt vs. Errtu. By the current year in FR I assume that Drizzt is now a 20+ level NPC.(add your own classes as you see fit) Errtu is and has always been a Demon Lord, a vassal of Loth or some such insanity. So Errtu is not your standard Balor demon. He sits on his own throne in the abyss. Not typical. Not standard.

Let's just say Drizzt is a Drow Ranger 10/ Dervish 10/ Divine Champion of mielikki 5. So that's a CR 26. Errtu must be a CR 25. IDK, maybe more as he is a demon lord. When it comes to a 1 on 1 battle, I would say that Errtu wins due to SLA and such. Drizzt has no spells to speak, although it's retarded that a ranger of his age and experience has no spells. Drizzt should be at minimum a 10th level ranger, commanding spells for the appropriate level. So dumb.

If you build your own Drizzt, then yes, he may have a chance against Errtu. As the current Drizzt is stated and then add 10 levels of experience, no. Errtu would wear him like a belt.

My personal opinion. It's very clear that Errtu is no simple Balor. But Drizzt is no simple Drow. I would say Errtu is a Demon Lord as he owns his own throne in the abyss. Drizzt cannot even cast a simple ranger spell. RAS needs to expand on that if his drow ranger is ever going to go anywhere. Otherwise just call him a drow fighter.

So Errtu wins in the end due to his innate SLA's and sheer power, not even giving him class levels in anything. Imagine Errtu as a 10th level sorcerer on top of what he already has. LIke I said... RAS needs to give Drizzt some Ranger spells at least. I mean, you can't keep calling him an amazing ranger if he can't even cast a single 1st level ranger spell. lol.

Edited by - Copper Elven Vampire on 24 Sep 2019 07:30:48
Go to Top of Page

LordofBones
Senior Scribe

961 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  07:32:25  Show Profile Send LordofBones a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Errtu has always been a typical balor. He was 13HD back in 2e when balors were 13 HD. He's not especially unique among his kind; the Lords of Woe also rule a layer, and they're just 20HD nalfeshnee.
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  08:33:51  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by LordofBones

Errtu has always been a typical balor. He was 13HD back in 2e when balors were 13 HD. He's not especially unique among his kind; the Lords of Woe also rule a layer, and they're just 20HD nalfeshnee.



Yeah cool.. so I guess all Balors have somewhere to sit then. NO!!

It specifically says that Errtu sits on his own throne in his Mushroom hell of the abyss. Remember Wulfgar pining at his feet as Loth came to collect him? It's wicked clear that Errtu is a Demon Lord of the abyss. 1 of 100,000 demon lords. The layers of the abyss are infinite as I hope you know. The Hells are 9 layers and much more put together. The Dukes of Hell will suffer no chaos.

If you think Errtu is a standard Balor then I wish you well. I guess that means Malkizid is a standard Solar with demonic attributes. lol. Too damn funny.

I bet my rogue elf slays your Necromancer before he can even say the word "bone". Ohh... what's that? Too late, you're already dead. Killed by a 3d6 roll Sneak attack! lol.
Go to Top of Page

LordofBones
Senior Scribe

961 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  08:52:19  Show Profile Send LordofBones a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Errtu has never been anything more than a balor in any edition of the game, nor has he demonstrated anything that makes him more special than a typical balor. The Lords of Woe have more metaphysical oomph than he does and are also 20 HD nalfeshnee.

He's so unremarkable that his layer isn't even mentioned in Hellbound, Faces of Evil or FC.

Unless you have an official source that states he's a demon Lord in the actual sense of having a portfolio and being a unique fiend, there's nothing that sets him apart from Glyphimor, except Glyphimor had the balls to flip off a goddess even while knowing that Orcus, his boss, was dead.
Go to Top of Page

Icelander
Master of Realmslore

1683 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  09:16:19  Show Profile  Visit Icelander's Homepage Send Icelander a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Copper Elven Vampire

quote:
Originally posted by LordofBones

Errtu has always been a typical balor. He was 13HD back in 2e when balors were 13 HD. He's not especially unique among his kind; the Lords of Woe also rule a layer, and they're just 20HD nalfeshnee.



Yeah cool.. so I guess all Balors have somewhere to sit then. NO!!

It specifically says that Errtu sits on his own throne in his Mushroom hell of the abyss. Remember Wulfgar pining at his feet as Loth came to collect him? It's wicked clear that Errtu is a Demon Lord of the abyss. 1 of 100,000 demon lords. The layers of the abyss are infinite as I hope you know. The Hells are 9 layers and much more put together. The Dukes of Hell will suffer no chaos.

If you think Errtu is a standard Balor then I wish you well. I guess that means Malkizid is a standard Solar with demonic attributes. lol. Too damn funny.

I bet my rogue elf slays your Necromancer before he can even say the word "bone". Ohh... what's that? Too late, you're already dead. Killed by a 3d6 roll Sneak attack! lol.


Standard balors are lords among demons, by virtue of belonging to the highest class of demon, but that doesn't make them 'Demon Lords' in D&D terminology. All balors are potentially capable (and most actually do) of ruling over lesser demons, sitting on thrones that tower over mortals and a variety of other demonic behaviour, but their high positions in the demonic hierarchy doesn't mean individual balors all have powers beyond the standard listed for their kind.

No more than human fighters, aristocrats or members of other classes gain special powers over and above other characters of their levels if they have noble titles.

Za uspiekh nashevo beznadiozhnovo diela!

Forgotten Realms fans, please sign a petition to re-release the FR Interactive Atlas
Go to Top of Page

Copper Elven Vampire
Senior Scribe

596 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  10:44:19  Show Profile Send Copper Elven Vampire a Private Message  Reply with Quote
What about Terezerez, Lord of The blackened Marsh?

Or Symphelthest, Queen of the burning bogs?

What about Abraxis... Daughter of Grazzt... Princess of Sorrows. Queen of despondency. Lady of Ice, Lady of death!

Cifinfrond... General of The Blood Wars?

Wraxaldorm... Keeper of the River Styx?

Charon... Lord of the river Styx?

Durmexal Durgan.... Lieutenant to the gates of Avernus?

All Balors... Each and every single one. Some male, some female. Ohh wait! did you think Balors were only males? lol

Sindafel Sardarion... an elf that was banished to the abyss during the Crown Wars. Transformed into a Balor to Rule over the realm of Grazzt as a general in war.

Sharlapinquill... Yochlol Queen of The Demonweb Pits. Huntress of Devils and Mistress of Loth.

Have none of you read this? All Balors... some are male, some are female.
Go to Top of Page

LordofBones
Senior Scribe

961 Posts

Posted - 24 Sep 2019 :  10:50:58  Show Profile Send LordofBones a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Charon is an altraloth. To be more specific, he was a marraneoloth that became an altraloth.

Nobody mentioned balor genders either. The fact that they have titles doesn't make them actual Abyssal Lords, either. The only balor that happens to also be an Abyssal Lord is Kardum.

I've never heard of the others, but I'm dubious of a guardian of the gates of Avernus being a tanar'ri, much less a balor, considering what happened the last time balors tried to meddle in Baator. I'm fairly certain, however, that Abraxis is really Abraxas, who's a different demon Prince with no ties to Grazzt.

Edited by - LordofBones on 24 Sep 2019 11:11:23
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 2 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic  New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Candlekeep Forum © 1999-2019 Candlekeep.com Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000